Thirty-pound felt is roughly twice as thick as 15-pound felt, covers half as much roof per roll, and is the version Florida's building code accepts under asphalt shingles. Fifteen-pound felt is cheaper and lighter, but it is no longer the code-compliant choice where felt is used. Synthetic underlayment is the third option, and for most South Florida re-roofs it competes with 30-pound felt on durability and installation, not just price.
There is a second point most homeowners miss. Underlayment is only chosen when the shingles above it come off. If your shingles are aging but still maintainable, the underlayment decision may be one you never have to make. Below we explain the felt grades, compare them with synthetic, and show what to check before you sign a replacement contract.
TL;DR
- 30 lb felt is thicker, stiffer and tougher to damage during installation than 15 lb felt. The Florida Building Code (7th Edition onward) requires 30 lb or equivalent where felt is used.
- The names are labels, not exact weights. No. 30 felt has had a 26 lb per square minimum since the 1940s, while No. 15's minimum has dropped over the years.
- Synthetic underlayment tears less, handles longer exposure and costs more per square foot in material. Many roofers in Florida choose it over felt.
- Broward and Palm Beach re-roofs have secondary water barrier rules, so the underlayment is rarely a simple choice. Confirm the specifics with your permit office.
- Before replacing, have a specialist inspect the shingles. A roof that qualifies for preservation can keep its existing underlayment protected for years.
Table of Contents
- What "15 lb" and "30 lb" actually mean
- 30 lb vs 15 lb felt: the practical differences
- Why 15 lb felt has fallen out of favor in Florida
- 30 lb felt vs synthetic underlayment
- Can you upgrade underlayment without replacing the roof?
- How to tell what is going on with your roof
- Find out if your roof can skip the tear-off
- Choosing underlayment when replacement is the right call
- FAQ
- Sources
What "15 lb" and "30 lb" actually mean
Roofing felt is paper or fiber mat saturated with asphalt. It sits between the roof deck (the plywood or boards) and the shingles as a second line of defense against wind-driven rain.
The "15" and "30" came from an old measure of weight per square (a square is 100 square feet of roof). Today the numbers are names rather than measurements. An article from the IIBEC, a building-envelope professional body, explains that the standard changed from "15-lb/30-lb Type" to "Type I/Type II" and then to "No. 15/No. 30". No. 30's minimum saturated weight has stayed at 26 lb per square since the 1940s, while No. 15's minimum fell from 13 to 11.5 lb per square in the 1980s.
So you will see these terms used interchangeably:
- 15 lb felt = No. 15 = ASTM D226 Type I
- 30 lb felt = No. 30 = ASTM D226 Type II
ASTM is the standards body that writes the test specifications. Type I and Type II are simply its category names for the two grades.
30 lb vs 15 lb felt: the practical differences
The differences you can feel on a roof come down to thickness, coverage, water resistance and how long the material survives before shingles cover it.
| Factor | 15 lb felt | 30 lb felt |
|---|---|---|
| Thickness and stiffness | Thinner, more flexible | Roughly twice as thick, stiffer |
| Coverage of a 3 ft roll | About 400 sq ft | About 200 sq ft |
| Damage during installation | Tears and punctures more easily | More resistant to damage |
| Builder material cost (2011 figures) | About 5¢ per sq ft | About 10¢ per sq ft |
| Florida code status where felt is used | Not accepted on its own | Accepted (Type II) |
The coverage figures come from Fine Homebuilding, which notes that a 3-foot-wide roll of 15 lb felt covers roughly 400 square feet while the same-size 30 lb roll covers only 200, because it is about twice as thick. It also says 30 lb felt is often specified in high-wear, high-water areas such as eaves and valleys.
The National Association of Certified Home Inspectors adds two useful points. Felt is water-resistant, not waterproof. And 30 lb felt is thicker and stiffer, so it resists damage during installation and protects the roof longer if it sits exposed to weather before the shingles go on.
The cost figures come from Green Building Advisor, a 2011 comparison of builder prices. Prices have moved since then, so use them for the ratio between products, not as a quote.
A worked example
Take a 2,000 square foot roof surface, which is 20 squares. Using those 2011 builder prices for material only:
- 15 lb felt at about 5¢ per sq ft: about $100
- 30 lb felt at about 10¢ per sq ft: about $200
- Vapor-impermeable synthetic at 11¢ to 15¢ per sq ft: about $220 to $300
The gap between the cheapest and priciest option is a few hundred dollars in material. On a full replacement that runs in the five figures, underlayment is a small line item. What the choice changes is how the roof performs in its first hard storm, and whether the roof passes inspection.
Why 15 lb felt has fallen out of favor in Florida
The Florida Building Commission's 2020 roofing fact sheet names the key change from the 6th to the 7th Edition: where felt underlayment is used, it must be 30 lb or equivalent (ASTM D226 Type II, or ASTM D4869 Type III or IV). The same sheet lists three ways to create a sealed roof deck:
- A full self-adhering membrane (ASTM D1970).
- Self-adhering strips or flashing tape over the deck joints, plus full-coverage Type II felt or a qualifying synthetic.
- Two layers of Type II felt or synthetic.
Palm Beach County's cities apply the same logic. The City of Boca Raton's re-roofing mitigation package cites Florida Building Code 8th Edition (2023) Section 706.7.2 and states that when a roof covering is removed and replaced, a secondary water barrier must be installed. Its three methods match the fact sheet: full self-adhering underlayment, tape or strips over joints, or two layers of approved underlayment.
Broward County sits in Florida's High-Velocity Hurricane Zone, where local product approvals and inspections are stricter than elsewhere in the state. Your roofer pulls the permit, and your city's building department is the authority on what it will accept. Ask your contractor to name the exact underlayment product and its approval number in writing.
A synthetic underlayment used for permitted work in Miami-Dade and Broward carries a product approval. Miami-Dade's published notice of acceptance for one synthetic underlayment line shows how specific those rules get: minimum lap widths, staggered seams, tin-cap fasteners at set spacing, and a maximum exposure time that depends on the product. That same approval says the material may not be applied over an existing roof membrane as a recover system.
30 lb felt vs synthetic underlayment
This is the comparison most homeowners actually face, because the roofer's quote will often list one or the other.
Durability and handling. Green Building Advisor's comparison says synthetics are highly tear-resistant and hard-wearing, while felt tears easily in high winds and under foot traffic. Felt also wrinkles when it gets wet and can crack in cold weather. Florida seldom sees cold cracking, but wrinkling after a summer rain is a real concern, because a wavy substrate can telegraph through the shingles.
Exposure time. In a state with daily afternoon storms, the roof can sit uncovered for days. The same guide says synthetics stay pliable and can be exposed for four to 12 months depending on the product, while felt does not hold up that long. Fine Homebuilding points out that asphalt-impregnated papers dry out and lose water resistance in sunlight, so shingles should go on quickly.
Fastening. Synthetics require cap nails or cap staples. Felt can use staples or roofing nails. Cap fasteners spread the holding force over a wider area and are required in many wind-rated assemblies.
Breathability. Felt lets some vapor through (the NACHI guide gives about 5 perms for 15 lb felt, rising in high humidity). Many synthetics are close to vapor-impermeable, which is one reason manufacturers' instructions matter. A product approval tells your roofer how and where each product can be used.
Cost. Per the 2011 builder prices above, 30 lb felt ran about 10¢ per square foot, vapor-impermeable synthetic 11¢ to 15¢, and vapor-permeable synthetic 20¢ to 90¢. Synthetic rolls are also bigger, typically 4 ft by 250 ft against 3 ft by 72 to 144 ft for felt, so fewer seams and fewer roll changes.

For a South Florida shingle roof, that adds up to a simple rule of thumb. Thirty-pound felt meets the minimum where felt is allowed. Synthetic gives you more margin during installation. A self-adhered membrane gives you the sealed deck that wind-driven rain demands. Our guide to self-adhered versus synthetic underlayment goes deeper on that last pairing.
Can you upgrade underlayment without replacing the roof?
No. Underlayment can only be replaced when the shingles come off.
Florida's own Hurricane Retrofit Guide says codes generally allow a second layer of asphalt shingles over an existing layer, but strongly recommends removing the old shingles. A tear-off gives the chance to replace damaged sheathing, re-nail the deck, add a secondary water barrier and install quality underlayment at relatively little extra cost. The FORTIFIED re-roofing checklist goes further for homes seeking that designation: it requires removing all existing roofing material, then sealing the deck using one of three listed methods.
That is the honest case for a replacement when a roof has truly reached the end of its life: the deck is soft, the shingles are failing across the board, or leaks have reached the sheathing. In that situation, specify 30 lb felt at minimum, or better, a synthetic or self-adhered system, and get the product name in the contract.
But a roof that is merely aging is a different case. Shingles that are brittle, losing granules or starting to curl are not necessarily at the end of their service. If they can still be restored, the underlayment below stays shielded by the same shingles that have been protecting it. That matters because felt is vulnerable to sun and moisture, as Fine Homebuilding notes, and it is only the shingle layer that keeps it covered.
How to tell what is going on with your roof
Before you let any contractor price a tear-off, gather a few facts.
- Roof age and shingle type. Asphalt shingles on a South Florida home often show wear well before a replacement is truly required, as we explain in why Florida asphalt roofs fail and how to extend their life.
- Surface condition. Look for granules in gutters, curling edges, cracking and bare spots.
- Leaks or stains inside. Ceiling stains point to water getting past both shingles and underlayment, and that changes the answer.
- A view from above. Photos from a drone roof inspection can show ridge, valley and flashing condition without a ladder, which is useful when you are comparing opinions.
- A written assessment. Ask what condition the shingles are in and whether replacement or preservation is the better fit.
If a roofer says you need new underlayment, ask whether the shingles themselves are the problem. Underlayment only comes up when the shingles come off.
What we tell homeowners about underlayment
At Shingle Roof Renewal, we are not roofers. We are the people homeowners call before they call the roofer. Underlayment questions, like 30 lb versus 15 lb felt, usually come up because someone has a replacement quote in hand and is trying to decide what goes under the new shingles.
Our view is that the better question comes first: does the roof need to come off at all? Florida sun, heat, rain and storms dry out asphalt shingles over time, causing them to become brittle, crack, curl and lose granules. Our certified Fresh Roof Green Soy Technology is designed to restore flexibility, slow deterioration and lock in granules on qualifying asphalt shingle roofs.
If your roof qualifies, you could save up to 80% compared to a full replacement, backed by a 6-year transferable warranty. A replacement is commonly a $15,000 to $30,000 decision, and most homeowners do not know their roof may still be maintainable before they spend it.
If your roof does not qualify, we will say so. An honest assessment is the point of the inspection, and then you will know exactly what to ask your roofer about felt, synthetic and sealed decks.
Daniellison
Find out if your roof can skip the tear-off
If your shingles are aging but the roof has not failed, a free roof assessment is the quickest way to learn whether you are a replacement candidate or a preservation candidate. We inspect the roof, assess its condition and recommend whether it qualifies for renewal. Our service is built for homes in Broward and Palm Beach County.

Start with our free roof assessment and bring any replacement quote you have already received. You can also read how Fresh Roof compares with standard roof rejuvenation or see our shingle roof renewal service.
Choosing underlayment when replacement is the right call
Sometimes a tear-off is unavoidable. If that is your situation, use this checklist when comparing quotes:
- Product name and approval. The contract should state the underlayment brand, grade and Florida or Miami-Dade approval number, not just "felt" or "synthetic."
- Secondary water barrier. Ask which of the code-listed methods is being used, and whether the deck seams are taped or the whole deck is covered with a self-adhering sheet.
- Fasteners. Cap nails or tin caps for synthetics, at the spacing the approval requires.
- Exposure plan. Ask how long the deck might sit uncovered and which product tolerates that. Felt's exposure window is far shorter than most synthetics'.
- Deck repair. Rotted sheathing must be replaced before underlayment goes down. The Hurricane Retrofit Guide treats tear-off as the time to re-nail the deck.
- Permit and inspection. Your city's building department has the final word on what passes.
The homeowner who asks those questions gets a better roof for a few hundred dollars more in material, which is often the best money spent on the job.
FAQ
Is 30 lb felt better than 15 lb felt?
For a shingle roof in Florida, yes. It is about twice as thick, resists damage during installation and protects longer if exposed to weather. Florida's code requires 30 lb or equivalent where felt is used, so 15 lb alone no longer meets it.
Is 30 lb felt really 30 pounds?
Not exactly. The number is a legacy name. According to IIBEC, No. 30 felt has a 26 lb per square minimum saturated weight, and today's standards use Type I and Type II designations. Ask for the ASTM type or product approval, not just "30 lb."
Is synthetic underlayment better than 30 lb felt?
Synthetics tear less, lie flatter, and tolerate weeks to months of exposure during installation, though they cost more per square foot in material. Fasteners and vapor behavior vary by product, so the manufacturer's approval governs how it must be installed.
Can I replace the underlayment without replacing my shingles?
No. Underlayment sits beneath the shingles, so it can only be replaced during a tear-off. If your shingles are aging but not failing, have the roof assessed first to see whether replacement is necessary yet.
Does Broward or Palm Beach County need a special underlayment?
Re-roofs in Florida need a secondary water barrier under the code, and Broward is in the High-Velocity Hurricane Zone with stricter approvals. Your roofer and building department confirm the exact method for your address.
Sources
- IIBEC: When is No. 30 Asphalt Felt NOT No. 30 Asphalt Felt?
- Fine Homebuilding: Choosing Roofing Underlayment
- NACHI: Mastering Roof Inspections, Underlayment Part 2
- Green Building Advisor: Synthetic Roofing Underlayments
- Florida Building Commission: 2020 Roofing Fact Sheet
- City of Boca Raton: Re-Roofing Mitigation Package
- Miami-Dade Product Approval NOA 24110602
- Florida Hurricane Retrofit Guide: Re-Roofing
- FORTIFIED Re-Roofing Checklist
- Drone roof inspection costs
