Fiberglass shingles are the only kind still made today, and they are almost certainly what is on your roof. Organic shingles, built on a paper-like mat, were phased out years ago. If your Broward or Palm Beach County home has an asphalt shingle roof, the useful question is not which type to buy. It is how much life your current fiberglass-based shingles have left and whether they can be preserved before you pay for a replacement. That is the question we answer in a free roof assessment.
TL;DR
- Organic shingles have a cellulose (paper or wood fiber) mat. Fiberglass shingles have a glass-fiber mat. Both are saturated with asphalt and topped with mineral granules.
- Fiberglass is lighter, usually carries a Class A fire rating, and is what manufacturers make today. Organic shingles were mostly Class C.
- Aging matters more than mat type: Florida sun and heat dry out shingles, causing curling, cracking and granule loss.
- A roof with flexibility left may qualify for preservation instead of a $15,000 to $30,000 replacement.
Table of Contents
- What the two shingle types are made of
- Are organic shingles still sold?
- Fire rating: the clearest difference
- Cost: materials versus a finished roof
- How each type handles Florida heat and humidity
- What really decides your roof's remaining life
- Where preservation fits
- Check your roof before you call a roofer
- Our perspective
- FAQ
- Sources
What the two shingle types are made of
Asphalt shingles have either an organic or a fiberglass base. According to the U.S. Forest Service, organic shingles use a cellulose mat and fiberglass shingles use a fiberglass mat. Both mats are saturated with asphalt and covered with mineral granules.
The granules matter. They shield the asphalt from sunlight. When they wash off, the asphalt underneath bakes and hardens faster. That is why granules in your gutters and at the downspouts are worth noticing.
Organic shingles carry roughly 40 percent more asphalt than fiberglass ones, which makes them heavier, thicker and more costly. Fiberglass shingles were developed in the 1980s and became the choice of most homeowners and contractors.
Are organic shingles still sold?
Effectively no. One industry account says the last major manufacturer stopped organic production in 2011, so every asphalt shingle made today is fiberglass. Another puts the discontinuation earlier. Either way, a roofer quoting you a new roof will quote fiberglass.
If your home is older, you could still have an original organic roof. Most South Florida roofs have been replaced since then, so a roof installed in the last 15 years or so is almost certainly fiberglass.
Fire rating: the clearest difference
Fire resistance is graded Class A, B or C, with A the most resistant. The National Roofing Contractors Association states that most fiberglass shingles carry Class A ratings and most organic shingles carry Class C.
In practice, a Class A roof is a real advantage where embers from a nearby fire can land on shingles. Our guide to Class A vs. Class C shingles explains what the ratings mean, and our fire-resistant roofing examples for South Florida homes show how this plays out locally.
Cost: materials versus a finished roof
Cost depends mostly on the style of fiberglass shingle, not on mat type, since organic is no longer a choice. Published 2026 figures vary by source:
| Shingle style | Installed cost per square foot | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Fiberglass, all types | $3 to $5 | HomeGuide |
| 3-tab | $3.50 to $4.50 | RoofVista |
| Architectural | $4.50 to $6.50 | RoofVista |
| Impact-resistant | $5.50 to $8.00 | RoofVista |
The same RoofVista guide notes regional variation of 15 to 30 percent is common. Materials are only part of the bill: HomeGuide puts materials at $1 to $2 per square foot and labor at $2 to $3. Tear-off, disposal, permits and decking repairs come on top, which is why South Florida replacements so often land in the $15,000 to $30,000 range.
How each type handles Florida heat and humidity
Organic mats can absorb moisture, which in humid climates leads to curling and biological growth. Fiberglass mats do not absorb moisture the same way. One Florida roofing company's 2026 comparison rates fiberglass at 15 to 25 years in Florida versus 10 to 15 for organic.
Fiberglass is not immune to our climate, though. Roofing guidance notes that UV rays damage granules and thermal shock from daily temperature swings causes cracking, and that effect is stronger in hot regions. Algae is also common in warm, humid areas, and zinc or copper-coated granules are used to resist it.
Wind is the other South Florida concern. Most shingles carry a 60 mph rating under the standard test, with specialty products up to 130 mph. Higher-rated products typically need six nails per shingle rather than four.

What really decides your roof's remaining life
Since your shingles are fiberglass, the practical issue is condition. Look for:
- Granules in gutters or at downspouts. Loss exposes the asphalt to sun.
- Curling or cupping at the edges. Dry, brittle shingles lift and crack.
- Cracking when shingles flex. A sign they have lost their oils and flexibility.
- Bald patches of black asphalt. One roofing guide says these point to one to three years of useful life remaining.
The same guide says a few curled shingles in one area on a younger roof are a repair matter, while widespread curling and granule loss across the whole roof mean end of life. Water that gets under shingles can also rot the deck and damage walls, ceilings and insulation, so do not wait on visible leaks.
Our asphalt shingle composition guide walks through the materials that signal a salvageable roof, and our curling shingles guide covers the most common warning sign.
Where preservation fits
A roof in the early or middle stage of aging can often be renewed rather than torn off. We are not roofers or roof cleaners. We inspect the roof, assess its condition, and tell you whether it qualifies for preservation and renewal. Our certified Fresh Roof Green Soy Technology is designed to restore flexibility, slow deterioration, lock in granules and extend the life of qualifying asphalt shingle roofs.
Our lab-backed claim: it restores about 50% of shingle flexibility, compared with roughly 20% for standard rejuvenation oils. See our Fresh Roof vs. rejuvenation page for the comparison, and our step-by-step flexibility guide for Florida homes for what the process involves.

Check your roof before you call a roofer
We offer a free roof assessment for homes in Broward and Palm Beach Counties. If your roof is a good candidate, you could save up to 80% compared with full replacement, and renewal comes with a 6-year transferable warranty. Renewal also avoids sending a whole roof of shingles to a landfill.

Schedule your free roof assessment and find out whether your roof qualifies. If you are in Boca Raton, Delray Beach or Plantation, we have local pages for those cities too.
Our perspective
Homeowners ask us whether they have fiberglass or organic shingles because they want to know if their roof is the problem. Almost always it is fiberglass, and the type is not what hurts it. Years of Florida sun, heat and storms are.
The mistake we see is calling a roofer first. A roofer's business is replacement, so replacement is the answer you hear. Our business is the step before: finding out whether the roof you have still has flexibility worth keeping.
That is why our message is simple: call us before you call the roofer. If the roof qualifies, you keep it longer and save thousands. If it does not, you will know before you spend.
Daniellison
FAQ
Is there fiberglass in asphalt shingles?
Yes. Modern asphalt shingles are built on a fiberglass mat that is coated with asphalt and surfaced with mineral granules, as the National Roofing Contractors Association describes. That is why people use "asphalt" and "fiberglass" shingles to mean the same product.
Do roofers still use felt-backed organic shingles?
No, not for new roofs. Organic shingles are no longer manufactured, so new installations use fiberglass. Felt is still used as underlayment beneath the shingles, which is a separate layer.
Which shingle type is better for fire safety?
Fiberglass. Most fiberglass shingles are Class A rated, the highest fire-resistance class, while most organic shingles were Class C. Our shingle fire resistance check shows what to look for on your own roof.
How do I know if my roof can be preserved instead of replaced?
It depends on how much flexibility the shingles still have and whether there is widespread damage underneath. We inspect the roof and tell you whether it qualifies for renewal, at no charge.
Sources
- U.S. Forest Service: Overview of Roofing Materials
- Bob Vila: Asphalt Shingles 101
- RoofOnline: Types of Asphalt Shingles
- National Roofing Contractors Association: Roofing Materials
- HomeGuide: Fiberglass Shingle Roof Cost
- RoofVista: Asphalt Shingles Guide
- Pinellas Roof: Fiberglass Shingles vs Organic
- Roof.info: Asphalt Shingles
- Innovative Roofing: Sloped Roof Systems in South Florida
- Inspectapedia: Asphalt Shingle Properties
- Global Roofing: Do I Need a New Roof?
